One Punch Man: Can Metal Bat kill Garou? Murata's comments, explained

The question of whether Metal Bat could have killed Garou in One Punch Man has sparked debate among fans, with Yusuke Murata's comments adding fuel to the fire. Here's a breakdown of the situation, incorporating Murata's remarks and exploring the arguments on both sides:

Murata's Comments:

• During a 2015 live stream promoting the series, Murata stated that if Metal Bat had landed a direct hit on Garou, it could have been fatal.
• This statement, while not definitive confirmation, suggests Murata believes Metal Bat possessed the raw power to potentially defeat Garou.

Arguments for Metal Bat's Potential Victory:

• Immense Strength: Despite lacking superpowers or formal training, Metal Bat possesses exceptional physical strength and durability. He frequently overpowers monsters significantly larger and seemingly stronger than him.
• Fighting Spirit: Metal Bat's unwavering fighting spirit and determination are his defining traits. He fights relentlessly, pushing himself to the limit, and never gives up, even against seemingly insurmountable odds.
• Unpredictable Fighting Style: Metal Bat's fighting style is unorthodox and relies on improvisation. This unpredictability could have caught Garou off guard, creating an opening for a decisive blow.

Arguments Against Metal Bat's Victory:

• Garou's Rapid Growth: Throughout their fight, Garou demonstrates exceptional adaptability and rapid growth. He analyzes his opponent's techniques and evolves his fighting style mid-battle, making him increasingly difficult to defeat.
• Garou's Enhanced Durability: As the battle progresses, Garou's body undergoes significant physical changes, enhancing his durability and resilience. Even if Metal Bat landed a powerful blow, it might not have been enough to incapacitate him.
• Narrative Significance: From a narrative perspective, Garou's eventual defeat comes at the hands of Saitama, highlighting the protagonist's unmatched power and reinforcing the series' core themes. A victory for Metal Bat might have altered the story's direction and undermined this thematic focus.

Remember:

• Murata's comments offer an interesting perspective, but they shouldn't be interpreted as definitive proof of Metal Bat's guaranteed victory.
• The outcome of the fight remains open to interpretation and speculation based on the characters' established strengths and the narrative context.
• Enjoy the debate and appreciate the different perspectives surrounding this hypothetical scenario without definitive statements about what would have happened.

Conclusion:

While the question of whether Metal Bat could have killed Garou remains unanswered, Murata's comments and the analysis of both sides provide valuable insights into the characters' strengths and the complexities of the hypothetical scenario. Ultimately, the true outcome remains a matter of speculation and individual interpretation, adding an intriguing layer of depth to the One Punch Man universe.

‍