Tomura Shigaraki: Alive and Kicking (…Maybe) in My Hero Academia

My Hero Academia fans were left with a cliffhanger in Chapter 379 regarding the fate of Tomura Shigaraki. While All For One seemingly declared him dead, the truth is more complex. Here's a deep dive into the events and why Shigaraki might still be alive:

A Desperate Mastermind:

• All For One's Endgame:  With his original body weakened, All For One aimed to fully inhabit Shigaraki's body and regain his former glory. This involved suppressing Shigaraki's personality.

A Flicker of Resistance:

• Shigaraki's Vestige:  Chapter 379 revealed that Shigaraki's own consciousness wasn't entirely gone. A weakened vestige of his personality remained, clinging to a fragment of his identity.

A Questionable Demise:

• All For One's Announcement:  After forcefully transferring his consciousness into his original body (thanks to a quirk-enhancing drug), All For One declared Shigaraki dead. However, there's reason to doubt this claim.

Why Shigaraki Might Still Be Alive:

• The Vestige's Tenacity:  Despite being weakened, Shigaraki's vestige showed surprising resilience. It could potentially fight back against All For One's dominance within the original body.
• Incomplete Transfer:  The success of All For One's consciousness transfer is unclear.  There's a chance the process wasn't fully complete, leaving room for Shigaraki's vestige to resurface.
• Narrative Significance:  Shigaraki has been a central antagonist for a long time. Killing him off-screen, especially after a glimpse of his remaining consciousness, would feel like a narrative disservice.
• The Unexplored Backstory:  Shigaraki's past trauma and motivations haven't been fully explored. There's potential for character development and redemption that wouldn't be possible if he were truly dead.

What This Means for the Future:

• The Shigaraki Vestige's Role:  If Shigaraki's vestige survives, it could become a significant factor in the future. It might influence All For One's actions or even attempt to regain control of the body.
• A Potential Power Struggle:  An internal battle between All For One and Shigaraki's vestige could create a fascinating dynamic within the original body. This could lead to unpredictable consequences for the heroes.
• Shigaraki's Return?:  If Shigaraki's vestige manages to overpower All For One, it's possible that a weakened or reformed Shigaraki could return, potentially as an ally against the true villain – All For One.

In Conclusion:

While All For One might have declared Shigaraki dead, the evidence suggests otherwise. Shigaraki's lingering vestige and the potential for an internal struggle within the original body leave his fate uncertain.  His potential return, whether as a villain or an ally,  would add a new layer of complexity to the narrative and create exciting possibilities for future developments in My Hero Academia.

‍